Anonymous user
Tahdhib al-ahkam (book): Difference between revisions
adding template:Shi'a Collections of hadiths
imported>Mohammad.Kh m (Category + more) |
imported>Shakeri (adding template:Shi'a Collections of hadiths) |
||
| Line 58: | Line 58: | ||
However, the book would have been too lengthy and digressed from its main purpose (writing a work in hadith) had the rest of it been written with the same method. Therefore, the author changed his method in the rest of the book, resting content with citing Shiite hadiths and reconciling their conflicts. He then decided to cite all or almost all hadiths regarding the laws of sharia regardless of issues raised in ''al-Muqni'a''. This is why he added the sections on [[ziyara]] (pilgrimage) in the first three volumes of the book. Therefore, the book was written with two different methods that differ in their elaboration as well as in the way they cite hadiths. | However, the book would have been too lengthy and digressed from its main purpose (writing a work in hadith) had the rest of it been written with the same method. Therefore, the author changed his method in the rest of the book, resting content with citing Shiite hadiths and reconciling their conflicts. He then decided to cite all or almost all hadiths regarding the laws of sharia regardless of issues raised in ''al-Muqni'a''. This is why he added the sections on [[ziyara]] (pilgrimage) in the first three volumes of the book. Therefore, the book was written with two different methods that differ in their elaboration as well as in the way they cite hadiths. | ||
== | ==Position== | ||
''Tahdhib al-ahkam'' counts as the most important source of [[ijtihad]] for [[Imamiyya]] in virtue of its containing much more hadiths in comparison with the rest of [[al-Kutub al-Arba'a]] (the Four Books). | ''Tahdhib al-ahkam'' counts as the most important source of [[ijtihad]] for [[Imamiyya]] in virtue of its containing much more hadiths in comparison with the rest of [[al-Kutub al-Arba'a]] (the Four Books). | ||
| Line 70: | Line 70: | ||
Some [[Akhbari]] scholars made an appeal to a remark by [[al-Shaykh al-Tusi]] in his ''[[al-'Udda fi usul al-fiqh]]'' and held that all hadiths in ''Tahdhib'' (as well as in the rest of the Four Books) are reliable. However, since al-Shaykh al-Tusi has made it explicit that some contradictory hadiths in his book are unreliable, the view was rejected by other scholars. | Some [[Akhbari]] scholars made an appeal to a remark by [[al-Shaykh al-Tusi]] in his ''[[al-'Udda fi usul al-fiqh]]'' and held that all hadiths in ''Tahdhib'' (as well as in the rest of the Four Books) are reliable. However, since al-Shaykh al-Tusi has made it explicit that some contradictory hadiths in his book are unreliable, the view was rejected by other scholars. | ||
{{Shi'a Collections of hadiths}} | |||
==Reasons for the Weakness of Hadiths in Tahdhib al-ahkam== | ==Reasons for the Weakness of Hadiths in Tahdhib al-ahkam== | ||