Jump to content

Al-Kafi (book): Difference between revisions

no edit summary
imported>Editor2
No edit summary
imported>Editor2
No edit summary
Line 94: Line 94:
</div>
</div>


== The Number of Containing Hadiths ==
== Number of Hadith it Contains ==
The number of hadiths ''al-Kafi'' contains has been reported differently. In ''Lu'lu' al-Bahrayn'', [[Yusuf al-Bahrani]] mentioned it to be 16199; in the preface to ''al-Kafi'', Dr. Husayn Ali Mahfuz mentioned it as 15176; Allamah Majlisi reported it as 16121 and some contemporary scholars such as al-Shaykh 'Abd al-Rassul al-Ghaffar counted hadiths as 15503.
[[Yusuf al-Bahrani]], in''Lu'lu' al-Bahrayn'', counts the number of hadith in ''Al-Kafi'' to be 16199, Dr. Husayn Ali Mahfuz, in the preface to ''al-Kafi'', counts 15176, Allamah Majlisi counts 16121 and some contemporary scholars such as al-Shaykh 'Abd al-Rassul al-Ghaffar consider them to be 15503.


These numbers differ according to different methods of counting; i.e some of them counted a hadith which is transmitted from two different chains of transmitters as two hadiths and some others have counted it as one. Some have counted ''[[mursal]]'' hadiths (those hadiths all the transmitters in the chain of which are not mentioned) as one and some others have not counted them at all. However, there are rare cases where some hadiths have not been mentioned in certain manuscripts.<ref>''Al-kulayni wa al-kafi'', pp. 401 - 402.</ref>
The reason for this variancy is due to different methods of counting. For example, some scholars count a hadith transmitted from two different chains as two hadith, while others count it as one. Some have included ''[[mursal]]'' hadith (those hadith which do not have a complete chain of transmitters), while others havn't. There are also rare cases where some hadith are not mentioned in certain manuscripts, and therefore may or may not have been counted.<ref>''Al-kulayni wa al-kafi'', pp. 401 - 402.</ref>


== Researches carried out on ''al-Kafi'' ==
== Researches carried out on ''al-Kafi'' ==
Anonymous user