Jump to content

Ali b. al-Imam al-Sadiq (a): Difference between revisions

m
no edit summary
imported>Vahid
mNo edit summary
imported>Vahid
mNo edit summary
Line 63: Line 63:


== Mausoleum==
== Mausoleum==
There are three possibilities about his mausoleum. There are mausoleum by his name in 'Urayd, near Medina, Qom and Simnan.
There are three possibilities about his mausoleum. There are mausoleum by his name in [['Urayd]], near [[Medina]], [[Qom]] and [[Simnan]].
===The Mausoleum in Qom===
===The Mausoleum in Qom===
[[Majlisi Awwal]] wrote in his autobiography that the buried person in the [[cemetery of Bagh Behshet]], Qom is Ali b. Ja'far 'Uraydi and added that he travelled to Qom because of the invitation of its people. Also, [[Mudarrisi Yazdi]] has the same opinion.
[[Muhammad taqi al-Majlisi]] wrote in his autobiography that the buried person in the [[cemetery of Bagh Behshet]], Qom is Ali b. Ja'far 'Uraydi and added that he travelled to Qom because of the invitation of its people. Also, [[Sayyid Husayn Mudarrisi Yazdi|Mudarrisi Yazdi]] has the same opinion.
 
===The Mausoleum and Mosque of Ali b. Ja'far in Medina===
===The Mausoleum and Mosque of Ali b. Ja'far in Medina===
[[Sahib Mustadrak al-wasa'il]] believes that the burial of Ali b. Ja'far in Qom is very improbable; because, firstly: there is no report about this in 'Ilm al-Rijal sources, secondly: narrator of Qom, who would travel to narrate hadiths, did not narrate any hadiths from him, and thirdly about 100 of Sayyids and [[Imamzadis]] (Imams' descendants) who travelled to Qom have been listed in the book Tarikh Qom but there is no indication about  Ali b. Ja'far or his travel to Qom in the book. Consequently, he (Sahib Mustadrak al-wasa'il) believes that Ali b. Ja'far was buried in 'Urayd located about one farsakh away from Medina. Nowadays there are a mausoleum and a mosque by his name.
[[Muhadith Nuri]] believes that the burial of Ali b. Ja'far in [[Qom]] is very improbable; because, firstly: there is no report about this in [['Ilm al-Rijal]] sources, secondly: narrator of Qom, who would travel to narrate hadiths, did not narrate any hadiths from him, and thirdly about 100 of Sayyids and [[Imamzadis]] (Imams' descendants) who travelled to Qom have been listed in the book ''Tarikh Qom'' but there is no indication about  Ali b. Ja'far or his travel to Qom in the book. Consequently, he (Sahib Mustadrak al-wasa'il) believes that Ali b. Ja'far was buried in [['Urayd]] located about one [[farsakh]] away from [[Medina]]. Nowadays there are a mausoleum and a mosque by his name.
 
===The Mausoleum in Simnan===
===The Mausoleum in Simnan===
In downtown Simnan, there is a mausoleum attributed to him.
In downtown [[Simnan]], there is a mausoleum attributed to him.


==Children==
==Children==
Anonymous user