Jump to content

Usul al-Din: Difference between revisions

added the supplement
imported>Nazarzadeh
imported>Nazarzadeh
(added the supplement)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Islam-vertical}}
{{Islam-vertical}}
'''Uṣūl al-Dīn''' (Arabic: {{ia|أصول الدین}}) or '''principles of religion''' or '''roots of faith''' are a set of essential beliefs in [[Islam]] that every [[Muslim]] needs to believe in; otherwise, he would not be considered a Muslim. [[tawhid]] [oneness of God], [[nubuwwat]] [prophethood of the [[Prophet Muhammad (s)]]], and [[resurrection]] are the three main principles of Islam. All Islamic sects believe in these three principles; but each one has special principles which separate it from other sects. For the [[Shi'a]], [['adl]] [justice of God] and [[imamate]] are the additional principles.  
'''Uṣūl al-dīn''' (Arabic: {{ia|أصول الدین}}) or '''principles of religion''' or '''roots of faith''' are a set of essential beliefs in [[Islam]] that every [[Muslim]] needs to believe in; otherwise, he would not be considered a Muslim. [[tawhid]] [oneness of God], [[nubuwwat]] [prophethood of the [[Prophet Muhammad (s)]]], and [[resurrection]] are the three main principles of Islam. All Islamic sects believe in these three principles; but each one has special principles which separate it from other sects. For the [[Shi'a]], [['adl]] [justice of God] and [[imamate]] are the additional principles.  


Believing in the principles of religion is obligatory; but there is disagreement as to whether certainty of the principles is required or supposition is enough. Also there is discussion over the sufficiency of believing in the principles of religion out of emulation ([[taqlid]]).
Believing in the principles of religion is obligatory; but there is disagreement as to whether certainty of the principles is required or supposition is enough. Also there is discussion over the sufficiency of believing in the principles of religion out of emulation ([[taqlid]]).
Line 6: Line 6:
Most religious scholars believe that emulation is not permissible in usul al-din and everyone needs to think about these principles for himself and accept them with certainty.
Most religious scholars believe that emulation is not permissible in usul al-din and everyone needs to think about these principles for himself and accept them with certainty.


== Definition ==
==Definition==
{{Shi'a-Vertical}}
"Usul al-din" is a [[kalam|theological]] jargon referring to the fundamental beliefs of [[Islam]] the belief in which is required for being considered as a [[Muslim]]. Such beliefs are called "usul al-din" (principles or foundations of the religion) because Islamic disciplines, such as [[fiqh]], [[usul al-fiqh]], the [[exegesis]] of the [[Qur'an]], and [[hadith]], are based on them. The word, "usul al-din", is contrasted to "[[furu' al-din]]" (ancillaries of the religion) which refers to the practical rulings of the religion.  
Usul al-Din refers to two different senses. The first sense commonly includes all Islamic theological principles opposite to minor issues in religion. In this sense, the Usul al-Din are theological principles which are to be thought about, and Furu' al-Din are the issues which are to be observed, whether followed or abandoned.


Its other application refers to the three or five theological principles of [[Tawhid]] (oneness of God), [[Nubuwwat]] (prophethood), [['Adl]] (justice of God), [[imamate]] and [[resurrection]]. However, often the three principles of Tawhid , prophethood, and resurrection are called Principles of Religion and the two concepts of justice and imamate are called Principles of School (School of Twelver Shi'a); yet at times they are all grouped together as the principles of religion.
Muslim theologians have referred to the principles of the religion in different ways such as "usul al-i'tiqadat" (Arabic: {{ia|أصول إعتقادات}}, principles of beliefs), "usul al-iman" (Arabic: {{ia|أصول إیمان}}, principles of the faith), "ummahat 'aqa'id imani" (Arabic: {{ia|أمهات عقائد إيماني}}, the main faith-based beliefs), and "usul Islami" (Arabic: {{ia|أصول الإسلامي}}, Islamic principles), and so on. However, what they meant to refer with these terms was not restricted to what are taken today as principles of Islam. In many cases, ethical and jurisprudential issues were also referred to as the principles of the religion. For example, [[al-Ghazali]] referred to all theological as well as many jurisprudential and ethical issues as the principles of the religion. He considered the [[prayer]] and [[piety]] as principles of the religion, along with [[monotheism]].


== Cause of Naming ==
According to [[Misbah Yazdi]], "usul al-din" is a conventional term which can be used in different meanings. In one convention, it refers to all belief-related propositions of the religion. In another convention, it refers to the fundamental propositions of divine religions or a specific religion. It might as well refer to the principles of a religious denomination; for example, one can say that, for the Shi'a, the principles of the religion consist in monotheism, the [[prophethood]] of [[the Prophet Muhammad (s)]], the [[Resurrection]], [[justice]], and [[imamate]], just as [[Morteza Motahhari]] has considered these five beliefs to be the principles of the religion according to the Shi'a.
Those who have made this title have called these beliefs as Usul al-Din [Principles of Religion] because they believe all Islamic sciences such as [[hadith studies]], [[fiqh]] and [[tafsir]] are interdependent on these principles. In other words, Islamic sciences rely on accepting [[the Prophet (s)]] and accepting him depends on knowing these principles.


Moreover, it can be noted that these principles are defined so that the distrinction between Islam and other religions as well as the distinction between [[Shi'a]] and other sects are preserved; such as, accepting imamate, separates the Shi'a from [[sunni|Sunnis]] and with justice, Shi'a are separated from [[Ash'arism|Ash'arite]]s.
==Instances==
The principles of Islam consist in [[monotheism]], the prophethood of the Prophet Muhammad (s), and the Resurrection. Anyone who believes in these three doctrines is considered to be a Muslim, and anyone who does not believe in any of these doctrines is not considered as a Muslim. However, there are disagreements among Muslims with respect to the details of these principles. For instance, the majority of Shiite and [[Mu'tazila]] theologians believe in the identification of God's Attributes with His Essence, but [[Ash'aris]] maintain that God's Attributes are over and above, and external to, His Essence.


=== Other Meanings ===
[[Morteza Motahhari]] emphasizes that the [[Imams (a)]] did not coin the term, "usul al-din", and says: it was coined by scholars in order to indicate the main goals of the religion, for there are many other beliefs in Islam in which a Muslim has to believe, such as the belief in [[angel]]s and the [[essentials of the religion]], such as [[prayer]] and [[fast]].
Sometimes Usul al-Din has been used to address a more specific concept. For example, it has been used to refer to the science of [[Kalam]] (Islamic theology).


== Usul al-Din in the Qur'an and Tradition ==
In the past, no particular criterion was specified for when beliefs count as the principles of a religion or a religious denomination. The significance of an issue in a certain period usually led to its consideration as a principle, such as the problem of [[Divine Justice]] that has no privilege over other [[Divine Attributes]], but because of major disagreements between the Shi'a and the Mu'tazila, on the one hand, and the Ash'aris—who constituted the majority of Sunni Muslims—on the other hand, it came to be considered as a principle of the religion for the Shi'a and the Mu'tazila.
This compound has been first used by [['Ilm al-Kalam|theologians]], and there is not such a classification of religious sciences to principles and other issues in the [[Qur'an]] or in [[hadith]]s.


However, there are hadiths that mention principles in Islam. For example, a hadith narrates [[Imam al-Sadiq (a)]] was asked, "What are principles? And what are the issues everyone needs to have knowledge about, should not be ignorant about, otherwise whose beliefs would be spoiled and God would not accept his deeds and if anyone knows them and acts upon them, his religion would be corrected and his deeds would be accepted?" Imam answered, "Declaring belief in oneness of God, prophethood of [[the Prophet (s)]], acknowledging what is revealed from God, paying [[Zakat]] and acknowledging [[Wilaya]] of [[Ahl al-Bayt (a)|the Progeny of Muhammad (s)]], among whom Wilaya is of special importance."
===Principles of a Religious Denomination===
In addition to the principles of the religion shared by various Islamic denominations, every Islamic denomination involves its own fundamental beliefs that are called the "principles of the denomination". For example, Imami Shi'as believe, in addition to the above three principles, in two additional principles: justice and [[imamate]]. Therefore, the principles of the Shiite denomination are five. Issues, such as [[enjoining the right and forbidding the wrong]] and justice, count as principles of the [[Mu'tazila]] denomination.


In another hadith, [[Imam al-Baqir (a)]] said, "Islam has five pillars of [[daily prayers]], Zakat, [[Fasting]], [[Hajj]] and Wilaya which is most important of all." Such hadiths show that some Islamic beliefs are so valuable that rejecting them implies a rejection of Islam, while the acceptance of other pillars do not result in the same implication.
==Background==
The term, "usul al-din," was not used in the [[Qur'an]] and [[hadith]]s, and it was coined by Muslims. It is conjectured that the use of the term, "al-usul al-khamsa" (the five principles), by [[Abu l-Hudhayl al-'Allaf]], a Mu'tazili theologian, paved the ground for the use of the word, "usul al-din". Since [[Ibn al-Nadim]] has attributed a book with the title, "usul al-din", to Abu Musa Murdar, some people think that the term was common in early 3rd/9th century.


== Deep Religious Conviction or Mere Conjecture ==
However, in some hadiths from [[the Prophet (s)]] and the [[Imams (a)]], some religious elements were introduced as tenets of the religion. For example, Sunni Muslims have transmitted a hadith from the Prophet (s) to the effect that Islam is founded on five elements: monotheism, the prophethood of Muhammad (s), the saying of the [[prayer]], paying the [[zakat]], [[hajj]], and [[fasting]] in the [[Ramadan]] month.
There is no disagreement over the necessity of believing in Usul al-Din, but there are different opinions about whether believing in Usul al-Din needs to be based on assured knowledge or if conjectural knowledge is enough. There are also debates regarding acquiring conjectural knowledge, specifically if it needs to be obtained through reasoning or if emulation is enough. Most scholars say that believing in Usul al-Din needs to be based on assured knowledge and the faith upon conjecture is not enough.


Their theory is defended with verses of the [[Qur'an]] and [[hadith]]s that criticize acceptance through assumptions such as "indeed conjecture is no substitute for the truth," (Q,10:36); "They follow nothing but conjectures and they do nothing but surmise," (Q,6:116); "And they only make conjectures," (Q,45:24).
==Requirement of Certainty==
The majority of scholars require certainty with respect to the principles of the religion. In his book, ''[[al-Bab al-hadi 'ashar]]'', [[al-'Allama al-Hilli]] claimed that scholars had [[consensus]] over this requirement, but [[al-Shaykh al-Ansari]] cited other views in this regard as well, such as the view according to which it is sufficient to presume, or have probabilistic knowledge (zann) of, the principles of the religion. According to al-Shaykh al-Ansari, it is implied by what is quoted from [[al-Muhaqqiq al-Ardabili]] and his student, [[Sahib al-Madarik]], as well as by the writings of [[al-Shaykh al-Baha'i]], [[al-'Allama al-Majlisi]], and [[Fayd Kashani]], that if a person merely presumes the principles of the religion, then he or she counts as a Muslim.


Contrary to the former opinion, some other scholars have considered a strong supposition for believing in Usul al-Din enough and have said that a strong conjecture makes the heart tranquil, and that in the view of religion, a true knowledge is not beneficial if not resulted in tranquility of the heart. Therefore, what is necessary with regards to believing in Usul al-Din is receiving certainty at the heart which is commonly called certitude. In certitude, there is no absolute protection from mistake; however, it is disregarded since it is weak, contrary to logical certitude, in which there is no possibility of conjecture.
Al-Shaykh al-Ansari himself holds, in his ''[[al-Rasa'il]]'', that the mere presumption of the principles of the religion is not sufficient for counting as a believer, and that given many hadiths implying the requirement of knowledge, one is obliged to inquire about such principles in order to achieve certainty, if possible. According to al-Shaykh al-Ansari, a person who has not achieved certainty is not a believer, because according to hadiths, knowledge is required for faith. However, such a person does not count as an unbeliever either, because there are many hadiths implying that some Muslims are neither believers, nor unbelievers.


== Emulation or Studying in Usul al-Din ==
==Taqlid==
Most Muslim theologians believe that emulation in Usul al-din is not permissible and knowing them needs to be acquired through studying. There has been general consensus on this issue as well.
According to [[al-Shahid al-Thani]] in ''Haqa'iq al-iman'', almost all Muslim scholars believe that it is not permissible to [[taqlid|follow]] other people in the principles of the religion, because the belief in such principles should be with certainty, but following other people does not provide one with certainty.


One of the reasons for this being impermissible is that the emulator either knows the truthfulness of the authority he is following or not: if he does not know, then he can estimate the error in the authority, and thus his emulation is not wise, since he is following what is not immune from error. However, if he knows that the authority he is following is on the right path, then he has either made this conclusion in three conditions: either out of transparency which is null and void, out of emulation which the number of people emulating whom is necessary, or through studying which is the only rational assumption in which the person may have concluded the truthfulness of the authority. This is actually not emulation and thus emulation in Usul al-din is invalid.
Al-Shaykh al-Ansari has reported that the majority of scholars believe that it is obligatory to inquire about and argue for the principles of the religion. However, there are other views here as well. For example, some scholars hold that taqlid or following other people with respect to the principles of the religion is permissible if it yields knowledge. Al-Shaykh al-Ansari himself believes that taqlid in Islamic principles is permissible, because what is required for faith by hadiths is knowledge, and not inquiry. Moreover, because of many doubts about the principles of the belief, one cannot obtain certainty even after a great deal of inquiry. [[Al-Shaykh al-Tusi]] also believes that a person who cannot personally inquire about the principles of the religion can follow a scholar in this regard.


== Usul al-din from the Viewpoint of Twelver Shi'a (Imamiyya) ==
Today, the first issue that appears in books of [[tawdih al-masa'il]] (or manuals of Islamic laws) is taqlid in the principles of the religion. According to the [[fatwa]]s of [[marja']]s, a Muslim should believe in the principles of the religion with certainty and on the basis of arguments. However, some marja's, such as [[Sayyid Muhammad Rida Gulpayigani]], [[Sayyid 'Ali Sistani]], and [[Lutf Allah Safi Gulpayigani]], have added that if one obtains certainty in the principles of the religion, even without any arguments or reasoning, then they count as Muslims.  
The most popular opinion is that Usul al-din includes three concepts: [[Tawhid]] (oneness of God), [[Nubuwwat]] (prophethood), and [[resurrection]], to which [['Adl]] (justice) and [[imamate]] are added as the Principles of the School. In other words, if someone rejects one of the three Usul al-din, he is considered a Kafir [unbeliever], but if he accepts the three fundamental principles but rejects either justice [of God] or imamate, then he is a believer, but he would not be a [[Shi'a]].


According to the common opinion of Twelver Shi'a scholars, the five mentioned principles are defined as following:
==Related Works==
 
In most of the theological works a chapter is dedicated to the discussion of usul al-din. However, considering the importance of the isuue, there are works dedicated to usul al-din. Some of the most important of such works is as follows,
1- '''Tawhid (Oneness of God)''':{{main|Tawhid}} Knowing God and acknowledging the fact that from pre-existence to post-eternity, He exists and is Necessary Existent. The concept of Tawhid acknowledges positive attributes for God such as infinite power, knowledge, and existence as well as rejecting negative attributes from Him such as ignorance, inability to do anything, or imperfection. This also implies believing in the fact that God's attributes are the same as His essence, and that He has no additional attributes to His essence.
{{cb|2}}
2- '''Justice [of God]''':{{main|'Adl}} Knowing that God is Just and Wise. This means that He does not do any wrong and does not abandon any proper act. God is not content with the wrong humans do. Therefore, humans hold the absolute responsibility for their actions, whether good or bad.
* ''Usul al-din'', by [[al-Muqaddas al-Ardabili]],
3- '''Prophethood''':{{main|Nubuwwat}} Acknowledging the prophethood of the Prophet [[Muhammad (s)] and what has been revealed to him. However, there is a disagreement on whether this principle applies solely to generally acknowledging what the Prophet (s) has said as [[revelation]] or if one needs to acknowledge the revelation in details. Some Twelver Shi'a scholars also deem it necessary for one to believe that the Prophet (s) was [[infallible]], and he (s) was the [[khatamiyyat|last prophet]].
* ''Haqq al-yaqin dar usul-i din wa ma'arif''a Farsi work of [[al-'Allama al-Majlisi]],
4- '''Imamate''':{{main|Imamate}} Acknowledging imamate of the twelve [[imams (a)]]. All Twelver Shi'a theologians agree on this as it has been considered one of the two required principles of Shi'a. All imams are infallible and guardians of religion. They are responsible for guiding humans toward the truth and everyone needs to obey them. This concept also includes accepting that [[Imam al-Mahdi (a)|The Twelfth Imam (a)]] is alive and in hiding, but one day he (a) will [[Reappearance|reappear]] with the permission of [[God]].
* ''Al-Arba'in fi usul al-din'', by Muhammad al-Ghazali,
5- '''Resurrection''':{{main|Resurrection}} This principle implies that humans will be resurrected one day in front of God, and their good and bad actions will be judged. All Muslims believe in physical resurrection which suggests that the body to which humans will be resurrected is physical.
* ''Al-Arba'in fi usul al-din'', by [[Fakhr al-Din al-Razi]],
* ''Usul al-din'', by 'Abd al-Qahir al-Baghdadi.
{{end}}


== References==
== References==
{{references}}
{{references}}
* The material for this article is mainly taken from [http://fa.wikishia.net/view/اصول_دین اصول دین] in Farsi Wikishia.
* The material for this article is mainly taken from {{ia|[[:fa:اصول دین|اصول دین]]}} in Farsi WikiShia.
{{end}}
{{end}}


Anonymous user