Anonymous user
Sukayna bt. al-Imam al-Husayn (a): Difference between revisions
Sukayna bt. al-Imam al-Husayn (a) (view source)
Revision as of 10:12, 10 November 2015
, 10 November 2015no edit summary
imported>E.amini mNo edit summary |
imported>E.amini mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 63: | Line 63: | ||
However, this report is not reliable, as Abu al-Faraj has narrated it from [[Zubayr b. Bakkar]] who was an enemy of the descendants of [[Imam Ali (a)]] and even all [[Banu Hashim]]. He made up false reports about [[Ahl al-Bayt]] to the point that they wanted to kill him; so, during the caliphate of [[Mutawakil]], he fled from [[Mecca]] and settled in [[Baghdad]]. Moreover, there is [['Umar b. Abi Bakr al-Mu'mili]] among the narrators of this report. He is so weak (Da'if) according to [[Rijali scholars]] that even some [[Sunni]] scholars refused his narrations and said that he is “a blight of blights”. | However, this report is not reliable, as Abu al-Faraj has narrated it from [[Zubayr b. Bakkar]] who was an enemy of the descendants of [[Imam Ali (a)]] and even all [[Banu Hashim]]. He made up false reports about [[Ahl al-Bayt]] to the point that they wanted to kill him; so, during the caliphate of [[Mutawakil]], he fled from [[Mecca]] and settled in [[Baghdad]]. Moreover, there is [['Umar b. Abi Bakr al-Mu'mili]] among the narrators of this report. He is so weak (Da'if) according to [[Rijali scholars]] that even some [[Sunni]] scholars refused his narrations and said that he is “a blight of blights”. | ||
Even Abu al-Faraj mentioned the improbability of this report and said, “A similar gathering to what was reported to be held by Sukayna bt. al-Husayn was held by an [[Umayyad]] woman, and I do not tell her name to anyone as long as I live.” | Even Abu al-Faraj mentioned the improbability of this report and said, “A similar gathering to what was reported to be held by Sukayna bt. al-Husayn was held by an [[Umayyad]] woman, and I do not tell her name to anyone as long as I live.” | ||
Furthermore, many poems which are attributed to her are not composed by her, rather by Sukayna bt. Khalid b. Mus'ab al-Zubayri, whose meetings and relations with 'Umar b. Abi Rabi'a, who was a poet, is well-known. | Furthermore, many poems which are attributed to her are not composed by her, rather by [[Sukayna bt. Khalid b. Mus'ab al-Zubayri]], whose meetings and relations with [['Umar b. Abi Rabi'a]], who was a poet, is well-known. | ||
Having similar name with Sukayna bt. Khalid b. Mus'ab, 'Umar b. Abi Rabi'a's wife, and, sometimes deliberate, confusion between them, resulted in made-up stories about her like what Abu al-Faraj has reported. | Having similar name with Sukayna bt. Khalid b. Mus'ab, 'Umar b. Abi Rabi'a's wife, and, sometimes deliberate, confusion between them, resulted in made-up stories about her like what Abu al-Faraj has reported. | ||
In addition, many of those poem gatherings were held by [['A'isha bt. Talhat b. 'Abd Allah]], [[Mus'ab b. Zubayr]]'s wife, who was famous for her poetic relations with 'Umar b. Abi Rabi'a. | In addition, many of those poem gatherings were held by [['A'isha bt. Talhat b. 'Abd Allah]], [[Mus'ab b. Zubayr]]'s wife, who was famous for her poetic relations with 'Umar b. Abi Rabi'a. | ||