Anonymous user
Maqtal al-Husayn (a) (by Abu Mikhnaf): Difference between revisions
Maqtal al-Husayn (a) (by Abu Mikhnaf) (view source)
Revision as of 12:21, 27 November 2016
, 27 November 2016→The False Version
imported>Morteza (Created page with "Maqtal al-Husayn (a) was the first Maqtal written on the incident of Ashura and martyrdom of Imam al-Husayn (a). Lut b. Yahya known as Abu Mikhnaf was the author o...") |
imported>Morteza |
||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
Maqtal al-Husayn (a) by Abu Mikhnaf was available until the fourth century A.H. but it was later perished like other works of Abu Mikhnaf. The famous present Maqtal of Abu Mikhnaf is a false unknown book which was probably written in the sixth century A.H. Here are the reasons proving that it is a fake book: | Maqtal al-Husayn (a) by Abu Mikhnaf was available until the fourth century A.H. but it was later perished like other works of Abu Mikhnaf. The famous present Maqtal of Abu Mikhnaf is a false unknown book which was probably written in the sixth century A.H. Here are the reasons proving that it is a fake book: | ||
The content of this book is very different from the content of Al-Tabari; as Al-Tabari has quoted reports on the incident of Karbala through only one narrator or even without any narrator from this book. | The content of this book is very different from the content of [[Al-Tabari]]; as Al-Tabari has quoted reports on the incident of [[Karbala]] through only one narrator or even without any narrator from this book. | ||
The first sentence of the book is: "Qala Abu Mikhnaf: Haddathna Abu al-Mundhar Hisham 'inda Muhammad b. Sa'ib al-Kalbi" (Abu Mikhnaf said: Abu al-Mundhar Hisham narrated a hadith from Muhammad b. Sa'ib al-Kalbi), (p. 5); while Hisham was a student of Abu Mikhnaf. | The first sentence of the book is: "Qala Abu Mikhnaf: Haddathna Abu al-Mundhar Hisham 'inda Muhammad b. Sa'ib al-Kalbi" (Abu Mikhnaf said: Abu al-Mundhar Hisham narrated a hadith from Muhammad b. Sa'ib al-Kalbi), (p. 5); while Hisham was a student of Abu Mikhnaf. | ||
In page twelve of the book it is said: "Rawa Al-Kulayni fi hadith …" (Al-Kulayni narrated the hadith). While Al-Kulayni was born about hundred years after the death of Abu Mikhnaf. | In page twelve of the book it is said: "Rawa Al-Kulayni fi hadith …" ([[Al-Kulayni]] narrated the [[hadith]]). While Al-Kulayni was born about hundred years after the death of Abu Mikhnaf. | ||
Mirza Husayn Nuri ([[Al-Muhaddith al-Nuri]]) in his book Lu'lu' wa marjan, stated on Maqtal of Abu Mikhnaf: "Abu Mikhnaf Lut b. Yahya was a grand hadith scholar and a reliable knowledgeable historian; his book Maqtal was a truly a reliable book, but unfortunately the original maqtal is not available and the current version which is attributed to him includes some | Mirza Husayn Nuri ([[Al-Muhaddith al-Nuri]]) in his book [[Lu'lu' wa marjan]], stated on Maqtal of Abu Mikhnaf: "Abu Mikhnaf Lut b. Yahya was a grand hadith scholar and a reliable knowledgeable historian; his book Maqtal was a truly a reliable book, but unfortunately the original [[maqtal]] is not available and the current version which is attributed to him includes some irreligious content which has issues against principles of Islam. However ignorant men with wicked purposes intentionally inserted new contents that damaged the reliability of the book and its narrators are not trustworthy either." | ||
==Restoration= | ==Restoration= | ||