Jump to content

Incident of the attack on the house of Lady Fatima (a): Difference between revisions

imported>Pourghorbani
imported>Pourghorbani
Line 55: Line 55:
In the fourth time, when ‘Umar went to take Imam Ali (a), Fatima (a) shouted: “O father! O Messenger of God! How much did we suffer after you from the son of Khattab and the son of Abu Quhafa?” Some of ‘Umar’s companions were moved to hear this and returned.
In the fourth time, when ‘Umar went to take Imam Ali (a), Fatima (a) shouted: “O father! O Messenger of God! How much did we suffer after you from the son of Khattab and the son of Abu Quhafa?” Some of ‘Umar’s companions were moved to hear this and returned.


According to al-Ya'qubi, Fatima (a) said to those who had entered her house by force: “I swear to God, if you do not go out, I will cry out to God for justice.” With this word of Fatima (a), all those who were in the house left. Abu Bakr Jawhari (d. 323/935) has mentioned in the book ''al-Saqifa wa Fadak'' that when ‘Umar forcibly took Ali (a) out of the house, Fatima (a) went to the door of the house and said to Abu Bakr: “How soon did you attack the family of the Messenger of God (a)! I swear to God I will not speak to ‘Umar until I meet God.” Following this news, Abu Bakr later went to Fatima (a) and interceded for ‘Umar and Fatima (a) was satisfied with him. However, according to the report in ''[[Sahih al-Bukhari]]'', Lady Fatimah (a) was also angry with Abu Bakr, because of [[Usurpation of Fadak|Fadak’s confiscation]] and she (a) was not satisfied with him while she (a) was alive and did not speak to him.
According to al-Ya'qubi, Fatima (a) said to those who had entered her house by force: “I swear to God, if you do not go out, I will cry out to God for justice.” With this word of Fatima (a), all those who were in the house left. Abu Bakr Jawhari (d. 323/934-5) has mentioned in the book ''al-Saqifa wa Fadak'' that when ‘Umar forcibly took Ali (a) out of the house, Fatima (a) went to the door of the house and said to Abu Bakr: “How soon did you attack the family of the Messenger of God (a)! I swear to God I will not speak to ‘Umar until I meet God.” Following this news, Abu Bakr later went to Fatima (a) and interceded for ‘Umar and Fatima (a) was satisfied with him. However, according to the report in ''[[Sahih al-Bukhari]]'', Lady Fatimah (a) was also angry with Abu Bakr, because of [[Usurpation of Fadak|Fadak’s confiscation]] and she (a) was not satisfied with him while she (a) was alive and did not speak to him.


In ''[[Tafsir of 'Ayashi]]'', it is also stated that when Ali (a) was taken out of the house, Fatima (a) went to Abu Bakr and said that “if you do not leave Ali (a), I will go to the grave of the Prophet (s) and I will complain to God with disheveled hair.” Imam Ali (a) sent [[Salman]] to Fatima (a) to stop her from doing so. Fatima (a) returned home when she (a) heard Ali’s (a) message.
In ''[[Tafsir of 'Ayashi]]'', it is also stated that when Ali (a) was taken out of the house, Fatima (a) went to Abu Bakr and said that “if you do not leave Ali (a), I will go to the grave of the Prophet (s) and I will complain to God with disheveled hair.” Imam Ali (a) sent [[Salman]] to Fatima (a) to stop her from doing so. Fatima (a) returned home when she (a) heard Ali’s (a) message.
Anonymous user