Anonymous user
Bisharat al-Mustafa li-shi'at al-Murtada (book): Difference between revisions
Bisharat al-Mustafa li-shi'at al-Murtada (book) (view source)
Revision as of 11:54, 21 August 2017
, 21 August 2017→The Copies
imported>Nazarzadeh m (Nazarzadeh moved page Bisharat al-Mustafa li-Shi'at al-Murtada (book) to Bisharat al-Mustafa li-shi'at al-Murtada (book)) |
imported>Bahrami m (→The Copies) |
||
Line 58: | Line 58: | ||
The available manuscript copies do not constitute of more than four chapters. Because of this, it is implausible that the chapters be more than these in [[Muhaddith al-Nuri]]'s opinion. But apparently, the chapters are more than four. [[Sayyid b. Tawus]] has narrated [[The Sermon of Sha'baniyya|Khutba Sh'baniyya]] of [[the Holy Prophet (s)]], a practice specified to [[Ramadan]] month, from this book, yet the mentioned khutbah is not available in the existing manuscript copies.<ref>Mujtahidi, ''Bisharat-i nabawi'', p.32</ref> | The available manuscript copies do not constitute of more than four chapters. Because of this, it is implausible that the chapters be more than these in [[Muhaddith al-Nuri]]'s opinion. But apparently, the chapters are more than four. [[Sayyid b. Tawus]] has narrated [[The Sermon of Sha'baniyya|Khutba Sh'baniyya]] of [[the Holy Prophet (s)]], a practice specified to [[Ramadan]] month, from this book, yet the mentioned khutbah is not available in the existing manuscript copies.<ref>Mujtahidi, ''Bisharat-i nabawi'', p.32</ref> | ||
[[Ibn Hajar]] in ''[[Lisan al- | [[Ibn Hajar]] in ''[[Lisan al-mizan]]'', in the biography of Isma'il b. Abi l-Qasim b. Ahmad Abu Ishaq Amuli Daylami, has stated that Daylami has narrated [[hadith]]s from ''Bisharat al-Mustafa'', but the mentioned hadith does not exist in these chapters.<ref>Mujtahidi, ''Bisharat-i nabawi'', p.32</ref> Anyhow, the available copies are: | ||
* The manuscript copy in Malik library of [[Tehran]] | * The manuscript copy in Malik library of [[Tehran]] | ||
* The printed copy in [[Najaf]] in 1369 AH/1950, in 299 pages. This copy is revived by al-Shaykh al-Hasan Jawahiri's effort.<ref>Tabari, ''Bisharat al-Mustafa'', p.12</ref> | * The printed copy in [[Najaf]] in 1369 AH/1950, in 299 pages. This copy is revived by al-Shaykh al-Hasan Jawahiri's effort.<ref>Tabari, ''Bisharat al-Mustafa'', p.12</ref> |